FOOD · YARMOUTH PORT · TODAY
"Fish Fry is Now Wednesday-Saturday!" runs across the top of the fish market page on Peterson's website, exclamation point included.
Read a few lines further and the same page tells it the older way. The fry, it says, happens twice a week, Wednesdays and Fridays. Notes left by visitors on travel sites, going back to 2021, name the same two days.
Two schedules on one page. They agree on Wednesday and Friday. The argument is over Thursday and Saturday.
Ten fried things, and not one price
The board, as the website lists it: fish and chips, a fish sandwich, a clam strip plate, a clam strip roll, fried shrimp, a shrimp po'boy, fried scallops, a hot lobster roll, a seafood cake plate and a crab cake plate.
The page posts no prices. It doesn't post a time for the fry, either.
The counter's regular business goes on around it. The market sells fresh fish, crab cakes, stuffed quahogs and its own seafood spreads, and the page says the staff will shuck oysters and clams and cook lobsters for you.
The fish counter is one department in a bigger store. Peterson’s own site lists a butcher, a deli, sushi and pizza alongside the fish market, plus curbside pickup and delivery.
What comes on the side of a fry plate is another thing the current page leaves out. A tip posted to Airbnb in November 2021 said the Wednesday and Friday specials came with french fries, coleslaw and tartar sauce. Ask when you call whether that’s still the plate.
The fish counter keeps its own hours
Peterson's hours page lists the fish market separately from the grocery it sits beside. The grocery opens every day at 7 AM. The fish counter doesn't: it's closed Sunday and Monday, open 10 AM to 5 PM Tuesday through Thursday, and 10 AM to 6 PM on Friday and Saturday.
The fish page itself says 10 to 6, Tuesday through Saturday. Both pages are the market's own, so midweek the honest answer is 5 or 6.
The hours page adds one more line, in capital letters: holidays and weather can change things. Thanksgiving is eight days out.
Before you drive for a Thursday fryer
Wednesday and Friday. Both posted schedules include them.
Thursday and Saturday. The banner says yes. The older text on the same page says Wednesdays and Fridays only.
Midweek, aim for before 5 PM. The hours page closes the fish counter at 5 PM Tuesday through Thursday; the fish page says 6.
No fry time is posted. Ask when you call: 508-362-2147.
918 Route 6A, Yarmouth Port. Next door to Peterson's Market (map).
Today is a Wednesday, and both schedules put the fryer on it. Call ahead for the hour.
Keep reading: where the Mid Cape fries its fish
Two more counters where the fryer is the story.
HYANNIS · THE HARBOR
A Hyannis family sold fish for decades. One pan outlasted the counter.
WEST BARNSTABLE · ROUTE 6A
The name on the bowl comes with a judge in the family.
Sources: Peterson's Market, fish market page · Peterson's Market, hours · Peterson's Market, home page · Airbnb tips, Peterson's Market (2021–22). Read Nov. 17–18, 2026.