FOOD · WEST DENNIS · ROUTE 28

The donut is named All The Sides. The Captain Baker Donuts menu describes it as an Old Fashioned donut "made with Gravy, Stuffing and Cranberry Sauce," and marks it available around Thanksgiving.

That's a menu listing, not a promise it's in the case on any given morning. It sits on a menu that runs from Halloween's Graveyard and Hocus Pocus donuts to a holiday list of Gingerbread, Peppermint Bark and Rudolph. The shop is at 485 Main St. on Route 28 in West Dennis. Its own Our Story page says it began with the 2018 purchase of an antique Victorian home with a carriage house, which Family Travel Magazine calls a historic carriage house. As of Nov. 11, the homepage posts 2026 fall hours of Thursday through Monday, 7 to noon.

Read the menu closely and it sorts the people in line into types. You probably know which one you are.

Two bases, nine glazes, 1,980 donuts

The builder. The design-your-own list runs in four steps: pick a donut, a glaze, one topping and one drizzle. The everyday options are 2 bases (Old Fashioned plain or chocolate), 9 glazes, 11 toppings and 10 drizzles. Multiply them and you get 1,980 possible donuts, by our count, if the worm, dinosaur and shark gummies count as one topping. Count each gummy separately and it's 2,340. That's arithmetic on the printed menu, not a promise that every combination is on hand.

The toppings run from bacon and Bavarian cream to Fruity Pebbles and Oreo crumbs. The drizzles include grape jelly and peanut butter.

The seasonal. Fall adds an apple cider cinnamon base, pumpkin spice, caramel and cranberry glazes, and apple pie, candy corn and Boo Oreo toppings. Fall specialty donuts include Country Pumpkin, Caramel Apple and a Pumpkin Spice Latte. The holiday list brings a gingerbread base and crushed peppermint.

Dye-free, unless it's summer

The careful eater. The site says the glazes are dye-free. The menu's own fine print carves out the summer seasonal glazes (lemon, blueberry, raspberry and watermelon) as not dye-free. There's a short allergen-friendly list too: vegan and gluten-free versions of the Old Fashioned, chocolate, cinnamon and crumb cake donuts, among others. Every one is marked limited availability, and the menu tells you to contact the shop to check. The menu also warns that decorating those donuts can bring cross-contamination or other allergens, depending on the topping. If an allergy is serious, ask before you order.

The purist. The everyday specialty list starts with the Old Fashioned and the Old Fashioned Cinnamon. It goes on to a Nor'easter, a Boston Creme and a Holy Cannoli.

A breakfast sandwich called The Skippa

The sandwich person. The breakfast sandwiches are named like a crew list. The Captain is egg, cheese and bacon. The Skippa swaps in sausage. The First Mate is egg and cheese, and The Sailor uses Canadian bacon. The Siren goes on a cinnamon raisin bagel with cheddar, bacon and Mike's Hot Honey. You can also put any of them on an Old Fashioned donut instead of bread.

The coffee list runs house dark roast, a local medium roast, decaf and a pumpkin spice for fall. The cold brew is called Jamaican Me Crazy.

What the menu doesn't print is what any of it costs. Prices for the donuts, the sandwiches and the coffee aren't on the page. The only dollar figure on the whole menu is $1.75, extra, for a gluten-free, dairy-free bun.

Before you pull in on Route 28

Thursday to Monday, 7 to noon. That's the posted 2026 fall schedule as of Nov. 11, so Tuesday and Wednesday are dark. We didn't find any winter or holiday hours on the shop's pages.

The dog-friendly part is outside. The site calls its walk-up window dog-friendly. That's the outdoor window, not an invitation indoors.

Prices aren't on the menu page. The only figure printed is the $1.75 extra for a gluten-free, dairy-free bun. Check the online ordering page or ask at the window for current prices.

All The Sides is seasonal. The menu lists it for "around Thanksgiving." That isn't a promise it's in the case on a given day.

Allergen-friendly runs out, and isn't allergen-proof. The vegan and gluten-free list is limited availability, and the menu warns toppings can bring cross-contamination. Contact the shop before you count on one.

Where. Captain Baker Donuts, 485 Main St. (Route 28), West Dennis (map) · 508-619-3491 · captainbakerdonuts.com

Keep reading: Mid Cape food with a Thanksgiving clock on it

Pies, sides and the dishes the Cape argues about every November.

CENTERVILLE · PIES

Then the phone rang at the Cape Cod Times.

WEST DENNIS · ROUTE 28

Sixteen seats, one seating, and a scallop price the chef didn't expect.

LOWER CAPE · FROM OUR SISTER NEWSLETTER

A Thanksgiving argument that has a side for everyone.